Urban Sheds vs. Big Box Store Sheds: A Modern Choice for Quality and Craftsmanship
- Jeremy Horning
- 1 hour ago
- 3 min read

When it comes to choosing a shed for your backyard, the decision often boils down to two options: a custom-built shed from a company like Urban Sheds or a mass-produced shed from a big box store. While both can serve the purpose of storage, the differences in design, quality, and business philosophy make Urban Sheds a standout choice for homeowners who value craftsmanship and individuality. Let’s dive into a comparison of Urban Sheds and big box store sheds to help you make an informed decision.
Design: Modern Elegance vs. Dated Functionality
One of the most striking differences between Urban Sheds and big box store sheds is the design aesthetic. Urban Sheds prides itself on offering modern, stylish shed designs that elevate the look of any backyard. Our sheds are crafted to blend seamlessly with contemporary home aesthetics, making them a beautiful addition to your property.
In contrast, many big box store sheds are stuck in the 1990s. While functional, their designs often feel dated and utilitarian, with a "cheap" appearance that can detract from your home’s curb appeal. These sheds prioritize basic utility over style, and their cookie-cutter designs haven’t evolved much in decades. If you’re looking for a shed that complements your modern lifestyle, Urban Sheds is the clear winner.
Business Philosophy: Local Craftsmanship vs. Mass Production
At Urban Sheds, we believe in celebrating individual talent and local craftsmanship. When you choose us, you’re not just buying a shed—you’re connecting directly with a skilled local craftsman who builds your shed onsite. This personal touch ensures that you have a reliable contact for future home projects, fostering a sense of community and trust.
Big box stores, on the other hand, typically serve as display outlets for large manufacturing plants. These plants mass-produce sheds using minimum-wage workers, often in facilities located far from the point of sale. The sheds are then shipped long distances and sit on sales lots for months, exposed to the elements, before being purchased. This industrial, impersonal approach prioritizes cost-cutting over quality and connection, leaving customers with a less satisfying experience.

Customization: Built for You vs. Off-the-Lot Uniformity
One of the standout advantages of Urban Sheds is our onsite, custom-built approach. Every shed is constructed from scratch at your location, allowing you to request changes during the building process to ensure it perfectly fits your space and needs. Whether you need a specific size, layout, or design tweak, our craftsmen work with you to bring your vision to life.
Big box store sheds, by contrast, are pre-fabricated and shipped as-is. These "off-the-lot" sheds offer little to no customization, forcing you to settle for a one-size-fits-all solution. If your backyard has unique dimensions or you have specific storage needs, a mass-produced shed may fall short. With Urban Sheds, you get a tailored solution that’s as unique as your home.
Quality: Premium Materials vs. Basic Construction
Quality is where Urban Sheds truly shines. We use LP SmartSide Siding, a high-quality material backed by a 50-year warranty, ensuring your shed stands the test of time. Our floor systems are built with pressure-treated lumber, protecting against rot and termites, so you can enjoy peace of mind knowing your shed is built to last. Every Urban Shed is constructed to our exacting standards, and we back each one with a 30-year structural warranty.
Big box store sheds, while more affordable, often cut corners on materials and construction. Many use lower-grade siding and untreated wood, which can lead to issues like rot, warping, or pest damage over time. These sheds may save you money upfront, but their shorter lifespan and lack of warranties can lead to costly repairs or replacements down the line.

Price vs. Value: Investing in What Matters
It’s true that Urban Sheds are priced slightly higher than the typical big box store shed. However, the value we offer far outweighs the initial cost. With Urban Sheds, you’re investing in:
Superior design that enhances your property’s aesthetic.
Local craftsmanship that supports skilled artisans and builds lasting relationships.
Customization that ensures your shed meets your exact needs.
Premium materials and warranties that guarantee durability and peace of mind.
Big box store sheds may be cheaper, but their outdated designs, mass-produced construction, and lower-quality materials often result in a less satisfying long-term investment.
Why Choose Urban Sheds?
At Urban Sheds, we’re more than just a shed company—we’re a brand that stands for quality, craftsmanship, and community. Our modern designs, custom-built approach, and commitment to using high-quality materials like LP SmartSide Siding and pressure-treated lumber set us apart from the competition. While big box store sheds may serve a basic purpose, they can’t match the personalized experience, durability, and style that Urban Sheds delivers.
If you’re ready to elevate your backyard with a shed that’s as functional as it is beautiful, choose Urban Sheds. Contact us today to connect with a local craftsman and start building the shed of your dreams.